Medicare’s physician fee schedule pays for about 8,000 different types of medical services—ranging from office visits to surgical procedures, imaging, and tests—that are delivered in physician offices, hospitals, nursing homes, and other settings. The clinicians who are paid to deliver these services include not only physicians, nurse practitioners, and physician assistants but also podiatrists, physical therapists, psychologists, and other types of health professionals. In 2022, the FFS Medicare program and its beneficiaries paid $91.7 billion for services provided by almost 1.3 million clinicians, accounting for just under 17 percent of FFS spending. As described in Chapter 4, most physician payment adequacy indicators have remained positive or improved in recent years, but clinicians’ input costs are estimated to have grown faster than the historical trend.
Beneficiaries’ access to care—In the Commission’s annual survey, Medicare beneficiaries continued to report access to clinician services in 2023 that was comparable with, or better than, that of privately insured people. Other national surveys and our annual focus groups with beneficiaries echo these findings. Surveys indicate that the share of clinicians accepting Medicare is comparable with the share accepting private insurance, despite private health insurers paying higher rates. Almost all clinicians who bill Medicare accept physician fee schedule amounts as payment in full and do not seek higher payments from patients.
The supply of most types of clinicians has been growing in recent years, although the composition of the clinician workforce continues to change, with a rapid increase in the number of advanced practice registered nurses (APRNs) and physician assistants (PAs), a steady increase in the number of specialists, and a slow decline in the number of primary care physicians. Despite the growth in the overall number of clinicians, the number of clinicians per Medicare beneficiary (including those in FFS Medicare and MA) has remained steady due to beneficiary enrollment growth.
The number of clinician encounters per FFS beneficiary has increased over time, with faster growth from 2021 to 2022 (3.1 percent) compared with the average annual growth rate from 2017 to 2021 (0.7 percent). Growth rates varied by clinician specialty and type of service. From 2021 to 2022, the number of encounters per FFS beneficiary with primary care physicians declined by 0.3 percent while encounters per FFS beneficiary with specialist physicians increased by 1.3 percent and encounters with APRNs and PAs increased by 10.4 percent.
Quality of care—We report three population-based measures of the quality of clinician care: risk-adjusted ambulatory care–sensitive (ACS) hospitalization rates, risk-adjusted ACS emergency department (ED) visits, and patient experience measures. In 2022, risk-adjusted rates of ACS hospitalizations and ED visits continued to vary across health care markets. Between 2021 and 2022, patient experience scores in FFS Medicare were relatively stable.
Clinicians’ revenues and costs—Clinicians do not submit annual cost reports to CMS, so we are unable to calculate their profit margins from delivering services to Medicare beneficiaries. Instead, we rely on indirect measures of how FFS Medicare payments compare with the costs of providing services. In 2022, spending on clinician services by FFS Medicare and its beneficiaries was $1.1 billion lower than it was in 2021. This decline represents a 1.2 percent decrease in fee schedule spending and is attributable to a 3.9 percent decline in the number of beneficiaries enrolled in FFS Medicare, as enrollment in MA continued to grow. However, from 2021 to 2022, physician fee schedule spending per FFS beneficiary grew for most types of services.
In 2022, payment rates paid by private preferred provider organization (PPO) health plans for clinician services were 136 percent of FFS Medicare’s payment rates, up from 134 percent in 2021. Survey data suggest that providers are increasingly consolidating into larger organizations to improve their ability to negotiate higher payment rates from private insurers (and to gain access to costly resources and help complying with payers’ regulatory and administrative requirements). Compensation and productivity data indicate that, while clinicians who work in hospital-owned practices do not necessarily earn more than those working in clinician-owned practices, they do tend to see fewer patients and bill for fewer services.
All-payer clinician compensation appears to be increasing at rates similar to general inflation. From 2021 to 2022, median compensation for physicians grew by 9 percent—a little faster than inflation, which was 8 percent. Over a longer, four-year period that includes the recent coronavirus pandemic (2018 to 2022), physicians’ median compensation grew by an average of 3.4 percent per year, slightly less than inflation, which was 3.9 percent over the same period. Median compensation for APRNs and PAs grew more slowly than inflation from 2021 to 2022 (by 5 percent) but kept pace with inflation from 2018 to 2022 (growing by an average of 4 percent per year). Clinicians’ input costs—as measured by the Medicare Economic Index (MEI)—grew 4.6 percent in 2022 but are expected to moderate in the coming years. MEI growth projections are 4.1 percent for 2023, 3.1 percent in 2024, and 2.6 percent in 2025.
Recommendation—Under current law, Medicare fee schedule payment rates are expected to decline in 2025, due to the expiration of a 1.25 percent pay increase that will apply in 2024 only and a 0 percent update scheduled for 2025. Given recent high inflation, cost increases could be difficult for clinicians to continue to absorb. Yet current payments to clinicians appear to be adequate, based on many of our indicators.
Given these mixed findings, for calendar year 2025, the Commission recommends that the Congress update the 2024 Medicare base payment rate for physician and other health professional services by the amount specified in current law plus 50 percent of the projected increase in the MEI. Based on CMS’s MEI projections at the time of this publication, the recommended update for 2025 would be equivalent to 1.3 percent above current law. Our recommendation would be a permanent update that would be built into subsequent years’ payment rates, in contrast to the temporary updates specified in current law for 2021 through 2024, which have each increased payment rates for one year only and then expired.
To promote adequate access to care for all Medicare beneficiaries, the Congress also should establish safety-net add-on payments for clinician services furnished to FFS Medicare beneficiaries with low incomes, with higher add-on payments for primary care clinicians. We estimate that the recommended safety-net add-on policy would increase the average clinician’s fee schedule revenue by 1.7 percent.
We estimate the combination of the recommended update and safety-net policies would increase fee schedule revenue for the average clinician by 3 percent above current law, but the effects would differ by provider specialty and share of services furnished to low-income beneficiaries. We estimate the combined effect of the two policies would increase fee schedule revenue by an average of 5.7 percent for primary care clinicians and by an average of 2.5 percent for other clinicians.